Live from Port Chester, NY, it’s Goose! Friday’s show at The Capitol Theatre, the third of five gigs for the band at the beloved venue this week, included another original debut—the second of the run—and special guest Jimmy Fallon.

The Tonight Show host, who welcomed Goose to his program back in December, was spotted in a Lincoln box early on in Friday’s show but did not take the stage until the encore. “He had us on his show, now he’s here on our show,” Peter Anspach quipped as the multi-talented Saturday Night Live alum took the stage.

Throwing it back to Goose’s bar band roots, Anspach grabbed his Stratocaster and joined lead guitarist Rick Mitarotonda on the Mack Rice-penned Wilson Pickett staple, “Mustang Sally”. The almost cliche cover, banned in some establishments among other esteemed classics like “Stairway To Heaven”, “Free Bird”, and “Smoke On The Water”, gave Fallon the spotlight to which he is so effortlessly accustomed.

Related: Jimmy Fallon Joins Grateful Dead Cover Band At Brooklyn Bowl Nashville For “Tennessee Jed” [Watch]

Fallon’s singing style walks the line between his go-to Mick Jagger impression and his jittery Van Morrison, with Goose quietly backing him up in a way that recalls a young The Band making its bones with Ronnie “The Hawk” Hawkins. Peter at one point offers a reminder of whose show it is with a nice Stratty solo for a quintessential rock band moment. Ever the performer, Fallon laid it all on the line by closing out the sit-in with a fall to the ground, writhing spastically on the stage as the band rang out the final notes in utter bewilderment.

Watch Goose welcome Jimmy Fallon for a cover of “Mustang Sally” to close out night three of five at The Capitol Theatre below. For a full recap of the show, head here.

The sold-out run continues tonight, March 11th. Find out how to livestream the shows here. Revisit Live For Live Music‘s full coverage of the Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday shows at the corresponding links.

Goose w/ Jimmy Fallon – “Mustang Sally” (Mack Rice) [Pro-Shot] – 3/10/23

Setlist: Goose | The Capitol Theatre | Port Chester, NY | 3/10/23

Set One: Animal, Flodown, Everything Must Go, The Whales, Turbulence & The Night Rays, Lead Up[1], Thatch

Set Two: Creatures, Red Bird, In Your Eyes[2], Arise, Hot Tea

Encore: Mustang Sally[3]

Soundcheck: Everything Must Go, In Your Eyes (this soundcheck is incomplete)

Coach’s Notes:
[1] FTP.
[2] Peter Gabriel.
[3] Wilson Pickett. With Jimmy Fallon on vocals.

Coach’s Corner: Mustang Sally was played for the first time since January 26, 2022 (91 shows).