Ryan Adams appeared for his eleventh and final time on The Late Show With David Letterman last night, but one performance wasn’t enough for the soon-to-be retired late night host. 

Ryan Adams Releases Three New Acoustic Tracks

Adams played “Starting To Hurt,” the same song he rocked at his second appearance on the show back in 2001. After the three-minute performance came to an end, Letterman pleaded, “A little more? Can you reprise just a little more? A little more of the same thing!” to which the alt-rockers obliged, repeating the same song, this time with the backing of Paul Shaffer and the CBS Orchestra. Watch below!

Ryan Adams “Starting To Hurt” on Letterman in 2001: