Umphrey's McGee Busts Out First "That's All" In A Decade In Savannah [Photos/Audio]

Umphrey’s McGee visited Savannah, GA over the weekend where the band played its first cover of Genesis‘ “That’s All” in ten years.

The cover arrived in the second set at the Johnny Mercer Theatre, amid what turned out to be a full-set sandwich of “Nothing Too Fancy”. Coming out of a healthy take on “Puppet String”, Joel Cummins launched into the iconic piano intro to the hit off Genesis’ self-titled 1983 album. Guitarist Jake Cinninger took lead vocals before handing them off to fellow guitarist Brendan Bayliss, while Cummins’ slinky organ work brought the cover home. Prior to Saturday night, Umphrey’s McGee last performed Genesis’ “That’s All” on May 2nd, 2015 at Brooklyn Bowl Las Vegas, per All Things Umphrey’s.

Listen to full-show audio of Umphrey’s McGee in Savannah, GA on Saturday via nugs and check out some photos by Robert Francis. Not a nugs subscriber? Start with a seven-day free trial. [Editor’s Note: Live For Live Music is a nugs affiliate. Ordering your nugs subscription or purchasing a download via the links on this page helps support our coverage of the world of live music. Thank you for reading!] Umphrey’s McGee will continue its spring tour with shows in the Southeast and Midwest this week before flying down to the Dominican Republic to play at the inaugural Tool Live in the Sand destination event. Find tickets and full tour dates here.

Umphrey’s McGee — Johnny Mercer Theatre — Savannah, GA — 3/1/25 — Full Audio

Setlist: Umphrey’s McGee | Johnny Mercer Theatre | Savannah, GA | 3/1/25

Set One: Staircase > Domino Theory, Cemetery Walk, Cemetery Walk II, Wellwishers, Front Porch
Set Two: Nothing Too Fancy > Puppet String > That’s All (Genesis) [1] > Hangover > Puppet String, Hiccup > Looks, It Doesn’t Matter > Nothing Too Fancy
Encore: Speak Up

[1] LTP 2015-05-02 (765 shows)